you2idea@video:~$ watch G0GuHkUbuEY [56:57]
// transcript — 618 segments
0:01 Secretary Bessant, welcome back to All-In. We appreciate you taking the
0:06 time to catch up with us and provide this first year in review. We're excited
0:11 to have you here and hear how things are going and what's ahead regarding the
0:16 fiscal condition of the US government, the economic condition of the US
0:20 economy, including how things are going for Wall Street and Main Street. And
0:24 finally, we'd like to broadly discuss some of the administration's policies,
0:27 decisions, and how they're playing out or will play out from your point of
0:33 view. I'll start us off and maybe to catch up on our last conversation. One
0:36 of the things that I've cared deeply about and which you shared an objective
0:41 around is getting the budget deficit below 3% of GDP. I'd love to hear uh
0:48 from your point of view how that's going and how things are looking for fiscal
0:52 year 26. the actions that have been taken and what you think's ahead for
0:55 that target. >> Good to be with you. Happy to review the
1:00 year, talk about next year. Uh there's a lot going on. I would c categorize 2025.
1:05 We had some important victories, [clears throat] some important policy
1:09 announcements, uh some important movement, but I as I've described it,
1:14 2025 was setting the table. And I especially on the economy, I think the
1:18 the feast and the banquet's going to be in 2026. To start with the budget deficit,
1:25 we didn't get much credit because it came out during the shutdown. The the US
1:32 fiscal year is on September 30th. We had a slight fiscal contraction for the
1:37 year. Wasn't much, but much better than the 2.0 trillion that was estimated. We
1:44 came down from about 1.8 trillion to 1.78. So, a a contraction nonetheless for the
1:52 calendar year. We're making great progress. And just to put it in context,
1:57 Biden administration, they blew things out try trying to get Vice President
2:03 Harris elected in the fourth quarter. So last year 2024 40% of the government spending occurred
2:13 in the fourth quarter as they had the un uh successful or their unsuccessful attempt to
2:20 convince voters that they uh weren't in a world of hurt. I forecast that we will
2:26 have approximately a 200 to 300 billion fiscal contraction uh for the calendar
2:35 year which is between 7 1% of GDP. We're going to end the year with nominal
2:41 growth close to 6%. So we will be bringing down the deficit to GDP. I
2:48 believe it peaked 6.8% 8% for the calendar year previous year and we're
2:53 going to be in the mid-5s. So, it's a very good start on an important journey
2:59 and I've said that I would by the time President Trump leaves office that we
3:03 would like to uh have something with a three in front of it which will
3:08 stabilize the deficit to GDP which is the important number and enable us to
3:13 start paying down debt. Scott, it seems like the tariffs have
3:18 had an enormously positive impact. It's given you a lot of tools in the toolbox
3:25 to work with. Why do you think so many people got it wrong? A lot of people,
3:29 I'm sure, that you've known and worked with in your prior life as a hedge fund
3:33 manager. What did they get wrong? What did they miss that you were able to see?
3:40 >> Well, I I a couple of things. I I think people didn't have an open mind. Uh they
3:45 became the Trump tariffs which immediately a large cohort. Uh whether
3:50 it was government officials, industry people, the general population because
3:55 President Trump wanted to do it, it must be bad. I I said the other day,
4:01 President Trump cured cancer but it caused dandruff. Then people would say,
4:04 well, you know, President Trump has caused a dandruff epidemic. [laughter]
4:11 And um look that there's a lot of orthodoxy that hasn't worked. If we look
4:15 back early early 2000s letting China into the global trading system that they would
4:23 become more like us and there was a point and I'm somewhat sympathetic to
4:29 the people who believe that but by 2013 when Xiinping came in and great writers
4:36 like Elizabeth economy who had been of that view reversed and said he's a
4:40 different kind of cat. It's no longer going to be Chinese policies with
4:45 capitalist tendencies. It's just going to go back to, you know, hard communism,
4:54 Leninism. And I I just think that it was a failure of imagination. I I've said
4:59 several times people and maybe we'll talk about it today when people ask me,
5:03 "What are you looking for in a Fed chair?" Said, "It's someone with an open
5:08 mind." If we go back to the 1990s, Alan Greenspan did a magnificent job because
5:15 he had an open mind that the internet office modernization boom was going to
5:22 create a productivity bonanza for the US economy. And he let the economy he let
5:28 it rip. And we had an incredible economy paid down a tremendous amount of debt
5:38 that by 1998 1999 with a combination of Clinton administration having gotten
5:44 religion new Gingrich and his policies there was talk the at the end of the 90s
5:49 that there might not be enough government debt to you meet the needs of
5:54 the financial system which is the opposite of what we have Now, so again,
6:00 I I would uh part of it was just anything the president does must be
6:03 wrong. Part of it was a failure of imagination. And you know, there there's
6:09 some very good studies coming out now that are showing why why everyone has
6:14 been wrong that the the measurement problems the on the increase in goods prices. There's a
6:23 study from not a friend of the administration, the San Francisco Fed
6:28 with 150 years of data, I would refer everyone to that that shows that tariffs
6:33 do not cause inflation, that they're actually disinflationary.
6:39 So, has anybody read that study? Scott, has that been, I would say, a part of
6:43 the conversation in the administration now that there's this new revenue stream for the federal
6:50 government, there's an opportunity to cut taxes and cut other sources of
6:54 revenue for the federal government and that could potentially accelerate the
6:59 economy. But balancing that question against the importance of cutting the
7:04 deficit, how do you think about the balance between using tariffs as a
7:09 mechanism for reducing the tax burden on the economy versus using the tariffs as
7:14 an incremental revenue source for the federal government to start to reduce
7:17 the deficit and pay down the debt eventually? David, before I answer that,
7:21 another thing I want to go back to is President Trump and one one of the
7:25 reasons for the success of the tariff policy or I I'll give you two reasons.
7:30 One is that President Trump has used them for national security. So the
7:35 tariff policy has become part of national security who's able to use the
7:39 tariffs to negotiate trade deals. when he ratcheted up some of the tariff
7:46 levels to 35 49 50% even 145 with the Chinese it brings people to the table in uh the spring the
7:59 president put fentanyl tariffs on Mexico they've all come to the table to help
8:04 and partner with the US government to end this scourge on our people we're
8:09 seeing fentanyl deaths drop We because of the the good efforts of China, we
8:15 made a good faith move and decreased their fentanyl tariffs by half down to
8:22 10%. So that's been national security. Same thing on October 8th when Beijing
8:27 announced that they were going to put a worldwide export license on any any
8:35 product that had 01% of Chinese rare earths in it, which would have ground
8:40 the Western trading system to a halt. President Trump was able to threaten a
8:45 100% tariff and the Chinese immediately came to the table. The the other thing
8:49 that I would say so so that's all national security. The other thing that
8:54 I would say that people missed that I was convinced of is that the Chinese
8:59 business model is based on volume. It's based on employment. It's based on a
9:05 5-year plan. And I I think everyone neglected the idea that despite the t
9:10 the tariffs, the Chinese were going to keep producing that it it's one of these
9:15 they may lose a dollar on every product, but they make up for it in volume. Can
9:21 we forecast these tariffs through 28 or do you think that we have to have
9:26 moments where whether it's the Supreme Court who's opining on one body of
9:31 language versus another may change your course? But do you feel confident that
9:35 we can forecast these revenues now out through the balance of President Trump's
9:38 term? >> Well, I I think the I think the revenues are are a combination of revenues. So
9:46 the the ultimate goal of tariffs the the revenue collection I think but of in a
9:53 way is a payback for the imbalances that have gone on over the years. But over
9:58 time the the real idea is to balance trade and reshore manufacturing and
10:04 bring our economy into balance with our trading partners. So what should happen
10:11 is over time tariff income will come down and US tax receipts will come up
10:18 whether it's from factory jobs or more manufacturing and through higher payroll
10:25 taxes. So you we will we will start off at this very high level then we will
10:30 rebalance and come up. So I I I think it's difficult to know the timing. We
10:34 know the direction. We know the destination, but the the timing is
10:40 difficult on terrorists versus increased domestic tax revenues. What what I can
10:44 say is when when I got into the investment business in the 1980s, there
10:50 was always a focus the on trade and how much were we making in the US and again
10:56 that everything made outside of the US is a decrease in US GDP. So, as we bring
11:01 it back, I think we're going to start looking more at the the content of trade
11:09 versus domestic manufacturing as a component of GDP acceleration.
11:14 >> As we wrap tariffs, we have a Supreme Court ruling coming in
11:19 January. What happens if that goes against the administration?
11:23 >> Well, I I don't think it's against the administration. And I actually think
11:27 it's against the American people and it it will be again as I said it it will be
11:34 a hit to national security and the the the revenues aren't the the focus here.
11:39 The revenues aren't the focus. The the the revenues can be replaced but all all
11:44 the things that President Trump has been able to do using tariffs on the national
11:48 security side will be will be jeopardized. >> Would you be able to just work with
11:54 Congress on them? seems to how the constit see seems to be how the
11:57 constitution was designed is that the congress would have this authority. So
12:00 why not just work with them? Is that the fallback plan? >> What why would you say congress would
12:06 have what authority? >> Well the constitution has tariff
12:11 control. So that's at least my understanding of the US constitution and
12:14 I think that's why there's a supreme court case. Correct. Uh well the we
12:20 we'll see uh the the president has has the right under AIPA the for licenses
12:29 we've also seen um it it was I I was at the Supreme Court and for for your
12:35 viewers a bucket list event should be going to see a Supreme Court hearing. It
12:42 it it it is in terms of any institution that is the closest to what our framers
12:47 designed and kind of jumped into business in 1789. It is probably it is
12:54 surely the closest to what you would have seen at the court. They're very
12:58 convivial with each other. >> Yeah. I listen to it. It's quite
13:00 compelling content. Yeah. >> Yeah. It's it's and to to be there in
13:06 person uh not not my political leanings but ju justice Kagan the was just an
13:14 intellect of towering uh impressiveness. I came away thinking I am glad that
13:19 Justice Alto is not my father because [laughter] he he he he
13:27 is smart. He is bombastic and when when he he got the knife into a couple of the
13:33 plaintiffs in a line of questioning and he uh move moves it around quite a bit.
13:39 So, [clears throat] um, but one one line of questioning in in this that one one
13:46 of the plaintiffs agreed on was so and it was either from Justice Alita or
13:50 Justice Kavanagh was you were telling this court that the president of the
13:55 United States can do 100% embargo but he cannot put on a 1% tariff and the
13:59 plaintiff said yes. >> Yeah. And that ruling is coming out in a
14:02 few months. It's >> January or February expectation. Yeah.
14:06 >> January, February. And Jason, to your question, u I I I don't know what the
14:14 ruling is going to be. My my guess is everyone, you know, I I think that
14:20 framing is very important in any issue. And I think the framing thus far has
14:24 been very poor because it's viewed as 01. It's up down. And I my guess is it
14:31 will be more nuanced. having been in the room for instance I I think uh many in
14:36 the media were at a different hearing than I was at. So when Justice uh
14:44 Barrett Comey Barrett said if we undo this it'll be a mess that was viewed as
14:52 just it will be a mess as opposed to I believe she was actually leaning
14:57 toward looking for a reason not to undo it because it would the refund she was
15:01 referring to the refunds the president has absolute ability or the executive
15:06 branch has absolute ability through 301's 230 32s and something called 122s
15:15 to raise revenue on trade. So using the IEPA is not a stretch of that
15:20 authority. >> Okay. So I I think the question and I really appreciate the introspection here
15:28 on year one and the optimism for year two. Wall Street, the tech industry,
15:32 we've absolutely loved the results in year one. My portfolio has surged. So
15:36 that's fantastic. Thank you. probably beyond my expectation, but Main Street
15:40 is particularly displeased with the Trump administration's first year. Your
15:45 net approval rating is the lowest on two key issues. Inflation net approval
15:50 rating down about 30% uh on average since the summer and on the economy 18%
15:56 net negative. And so this is quite paradoxical obviously since Trump was
16:01 elected and considered historically very strong on those two specific issues. So
16:06 my question to you is, are the American people wrong? Or maybe did President
16:11 Trump set expectations too high during the election or do you just need more
16:15 time to execute and you're asking the American people humbly to give you more
16:18 time? >> Well, I I I think it's C because as Vice President Vance has said, we didn't get
16:27 here overnight. We inherited a mess. And I think 2026 is going to be a a very
16:33 good year for the American people for Main Street. And what we are not going
16:39 to do is a which is what the Biden administration did and many commentators
16:44 whether it was Greg in the Wall Street Journal, the toxic Paul Krugman who I
16:48 seems to have been booted from the New York Times and is relegated to Substack
16:53 or the former vice chair of the Fed uh Alan Blinder. And they said, "Oh, no.
16:57 You don't understand how good you have it. You know, eat eat your drink your
17:03 grog, have your bread, peasants. Um, we we'll give you a little more that you
17:10 It's a vibe session. And we're going to explain to you why you have it really
17:14 good. We understand that the American people are hurting. And I think the way
17:18 to think about it is there's a price level that things appreciated to during
17:24 the Biden administration. And then there is the inflation level. The price level
17:30 has gotten very high. Uh I think cumulative CPI during the Biden
17:36 administration was 21 22%. There's a Wall Street firm called Strategus
17:39 Research. They do something called the common man index and it it is what do
17:45 working families need? gasoline insurance, the uh autos, mostly used
17:51 cars, rent, staples, and that appreciated by about 35%. So, people are seething over the
18:01 high price level. And you as we saw in the inflation print this week, inflation
18:09 is starting to turn down. And affordabil affordability is two parts. It is
18:16 getting the price is under control. Some things we can decrease. Gasoline is
18:21 coming down substantially. I would expect that it would come down much
18:26 more. Oil. Oil is down substantially. Gasoline follows it with a lag. Uh rents
18:32 are down and we are now seeing uh the effects of what 10 to 20 million
18:37 undocumented people coming into the country did for rents. that this mass
18:43 unfettered immigration for D and C rent levels was through the roof. There
18:47 there's a study from Wharton that shows that one 1% of population increase in in
18:55 a city leads to 1% rent. So, you know, we can see why rent went up that if the
19:00 migrants are going home, we are now seeing rents are down about 5%. I think
19:06 that trend will continue. Again, the inflation numbers are starting to roll
19:10 down. I think that they will. And then the other side is real incomes, which I
19:16 think are starting to accelerate. Real incomes are about up about 1.8% since
19:21 President Trump took office. And that's back to the Main Street question.
19:25 >> So, just one quick followup there and I'll give it back to my compatriots.
19:30 We need more time. This is not a one-year project. It's going to take two
19:33 or three years and we're not going to gaslight you and the numbers are looking
19:39 good. On that note, we had the shutdown October numbers were not complete.
19:43 There's a bunch of reports now uh and hand ringing over those numbers. I think
19:47 maybe you could address it, which is the BLS filled in a lot of the non-servey
19:54 data sources with some zeros. Uh and potentially the criticism now or the
19:59 concern on Wall Street and from analysts is that maybe this 2.7 number is over
20:05 optimistic. maybe you could address people's concerns and can we trust you
20:08 with the numbers I think is what Wall Street saying. >> Uh well, you know, again, it it's
20:14 amazing when a good number comes out, then it switches to that. And Jason,
20:20 just let me tell you, every every Wall Street predictor on Bloomberg was wrong.
20:25 So, what do you do when you're wrong? You blame the measurement. You blame the
20:30 the data. And there there's always a lot of imputed data the in any of these
20:35 numbers. That's why we get revisions. And I I'm looking at I was looking at
20:40 the numbers and paradoxically the two things that I think are coming down the
20:46 fastest which are rent uh also it's known as the owner owner occupied uh
20:53 funding or owner occupied rent. Uh that was actually up on the month. I believe
20:59 it is uh turned negative. And then the other thing that was up was energy and
21:04 gasoline which we can is an observable event that those prices have decreased
21:11 substantially uh from September October. So I I actually think it was a a pretty
21:15 uh accurate number. >> So you've checked into that the BLS
21:19 numbers from October. You feel confident they they put those placeholders. They
21:23 put those assumptions in correctly. You feel confident in that? Look, the the
21:28 the BLS is problematic. We we've seen that the whole time. I have no reason to
21:33 believe that this is any less robust than any other data series. And I I
21:40 would say with with rent, with uh energy that those are very large components
21:45 that have turned down substantially that actually recorded a gain for that
21:49 measurement period. Just to build on that, we had people on our team go and
21:55 run our own analysis both using interpolation and other data
21:59 points and we get to exactly Scott's numbers and frankly on on the margin
22:03 sometimes slightly better. So I think the trend is very much what you and
22:08 Kevin Hasset have been talking about in the last couple days. And gentlemen, I
22:13 would also point you to Fed Governor Steven Myron, who came came from CEA,
22:19 he'll be going back to CA probably in February or March, delivered a very
22:25 robust uh speech at Colombia. It was either a week or two ago and he made
22:30 some very interesting measurement points on inflation. So one one piece of the
22:36 inflation component there is financial services and that goes up based on
22:41 whether the stock market's up. >> That's right. >> When in fact portfolio management costs
22:47 have come down that it is showing an increase in cost. So that back to
22:54 Jason's question on BL BLS uh how how robust are the numbers? I I think there
22:58 are a lot of changes that could be adjusted to give us a better picture.
23:03 Let's stay on the affordability topic and I would like to go to this essay you
23:07 wrote which is uh incredible the Fed's new gain of function monetary policy
23:11 which you wrote in the international economy. We'll link to this article. A
23:17 lot of it goes to how the Fed in many ways has exacerbated the sense of
23:21 inequality and the actual factual inequality. But before I ask you that
23:26 narrow question, Scott, can you help our viewers just take a step back and give
23:31 us a little bit of historical context on the Fed itself? So, we had a central
23:37 bank in the 1700s, in the 1800s. Andrew Jackson got rid of it. It came back in
23:41 the early 1900s. when we established it then versus what it's doing today and you've
23:49 studied this carefully. Can you help us understand and contrast and compare how
23:54 it started versus how it's going? >> Sure. So, Fed was created in 1913 as a
24:00 response to the panic of 1907 which people most people don't know about. It
24:04 made the crash of 29 look like a day at the beach. >> Nickerbacher crisis. Yeah,
24:10 >> the necrobacher crisis and just the a domino effect within the financial
24:16 system there there was no central bank. Bank of England is a very old central
24:21 bank and had been functioning well. uh JP Morgan actually had to personally
24:28 step in uh in in the crisis and it it was deemed that there should be a
24:31 mechanism for the the government to be able to uh either wind down, provide
24:36 liquidity and have have a greater control in the economy rather than priv
24:42 private operators. For much of its history, uh Treasury uh had a seat at
24:47 the table on the Federal Reserve. Post World War II that stopped. And [snorts]
24:53 then if we look at more recent history, what happened after the great financial
24:58 crisis? We saw this paralysis in the economy. I think a huge part of it which
25:03 has been part of my regulatory agenda here at Treasury this year through the
25:08 financial stability oversight council is undoing these the poorly thoughtout
25:13 crisis crisis legislation. But what the crisis legislation did and
25:21 look after financial I I've studied and taught at Yale the history of financial
25:26 crisis there's always retribution and you you go from a lack regulatory regime
25:31 to an over constricted regulatory regime. So coming out of the traumatic
25:40 GFC for for 10 years we had this over constricted regulatory regime where the
25:44 Fed was deemed to be the only game in town. So you know imagine
25:52 one one example would be a a home in North Florida that sold for $500,000 in
25:58 2006. All of a sudden people are handing the keys back. It is now $150,000.
26:04 Great buy, great affordability, but because of the new financial regulation
26:09 and the incentives that the the banks were in some cases rightly taken to the
26:14 woodshed for bad behavior, but there was no incentive to give credit at the
26:20 bottom. So what happened the asset owners, people with money were able to
26:25 accumulate assets. We saw very poor growth during the period during the
26:31 Obama administration and the the Fed cap kept rates low for very long. But what
26:37 the Fed engaged in starting I believe was October 6 o excuse me March 6 or
26:44 March 8th uh 2009 was the Fed began began what we call QE or largecale asset
26:50 purchases. They went went in the market started buying long bonds and the theory
26:55 of the case there is you create liquidity you take safe assets out of
27:01 the market uh long duration safe assets and then the people who receive that
27:09 money uh would buy uh more risky assets. Ben Bernani famously said when he was
27:14 asked what's the purpose of QE he told everyone go buy equities. Well not
27:19 everyone could buy equities. So, we we ended up with like this this two-tier
27:25 economy where either you were an asset holder or you weren't and that the Fed
27:32 constant probably kept or definitely kept QE going for too long. And you
27:37 know, I I called the Fed the engine of inequality. And someone said to me,
27:42 well, do you believe that the Fed is responsible for economic equality in the
27:47 system? And I said, absolutely not. that is not one of their mandates, but they
27:52 shouldn't be exacerbating it and they were the the leading cause of it. There
27:59 there's a fantastic book by a I I know Karen Pedaru very well. Uh she's center
28:04 left to maybe hard. >> Yeah. Not not your politics for sure.
28:08 >> Not my politics, but her book, The Fed, the Engine,
28:11 >> her book is excellent. Yeah. >> Engine of inequality. So we just kept
28:16 pushing up these asset prices and then then we got co and uh markets became
28:23 disorderly and the Fed did exactly what it should do. It came in, it stabilized
28:28 the market, but for some reason they decided that they needed to continue
28:36 this QE right up until the 20 I think February March of 2023
28:43 and they were in essence financing this massive debt increase 7 trillion that we
28:48 that we saw during that period. So, as a long way of saying the central bank has
28:52 become much more involved in the economy. I think a lot of people don't
28:57 understand we've gone from what used to be fairly straightforward rate setting
29:04 mechanism to now we have kind of this three-headed beast at the Fed or this
29:09 very complex calculus that I don't think anyone really understands myself
29:15 included. uh you have rate setting policy, you have uh balance sheet
29:19 policy. So the Fed has a very big balance sheet now. And then you have
29:23 regulatory. >> Well, there's a part of your article which was stunning to me where you
29:29 describe how the budget of the Fed works and effectively when you understand that
29:33 there's a part of the Fed which acts like a hedge fund and effectively is
29:38 taking risk and the revenues that they generate are used to subsidize their
29:42 operations. Can you explain that for folks cuz I I didn't fully realize that
29:45 that was happening. >> Yeah. Well, well, again, the that the
29:51 Fed should make money. Fed typically you used to make money and would remit money
29:57 back to the Treasury. And back to to David's question of the budget deficit,
30:02 the the Fed was sending back about 3% of GDP through we have senior which is the float on the
30:11 currency. uh there are other operations but then they started QE and no one told
30:16 the Fed that you know you're not supposed to buy high so they they they paid a high high price
30:25 for bonds low interest rates and they're arbitrage the Fed's losing about hundred
30:29 billion dollars a year now >> if you look at one of the key drivers of
30:36 Main Street's satisfaction with their economic standing it's the price of
30:41 debt, the ability for them to buy a home, to buy a car, to extend their
30:46 lives, and we've got the 10-year Treasury sitting, I think, 42 to 46
30:51 right now in terms of the rate. And I guess this may be a question that brings
30:55 in two other issues, the fiscal issue and the economic issue. Is that a
31:01 reflection of the state of the fiscal affairs of the federal government, the
31:05 state of the economy, both or the state of markets selling off bonds? And
31:09 doesn't the Fed have an important role to play in bringing those rates down and
31:14 making rates accessible for Main Street? >> Well, I I think what the the Fed did,
31:19 unfortunately, they took modern monetary theory from I say they went from MMT,
31:24 modern monetary theory to MMP, modern monetary practice. So that the the the
31:30 Biden administration issued all this debt and the Fed the Fed bought it. And
31:36 there there's a very good study from MIT that's come out that shows uh you know
31:42 in a way that only PhDs at MIT can be very precise. 42% of the great inflation
31:47 was caused by the budget deficit. Another 17% was caused by the increase
31:52 in inflation expectations which I think you could tie back to that. So you've
31:56 got almost 60% David that was caused by the spending of the inflation. And I
32:03 think what again to go back to my earlier point, I think what we're not
32:07 getting credit for here is that if we can stabilize the budget deficit, even
32:13 bring it down, that that will contribute to disinflation. If I think about
32:19 central bank credibility, no in my career, probably post World War II, no
32:24 central bank had more credibility than the Bundus Bank uh up until the advent
32:30 of the euro. But they controlled the ger they worked with the German government
32:35 and they would work with each other hand in hand. The Bundus bank would say if
32:42 you give us the fiscal control if you give us if you are not prolificate if
32:47 you give us the reasonable fiscal balance we will work with you we will
32:53 foam the runway to allow you to decrease spending. We will decrease interest
32:58 rates. And I I I think that's something we could be doing here. I
33:02 >> I'm I'm glad that you too are confused by the Fed's actions, Secretary Besson,
33:08 because I read your article and while I understand the mandate to get to 2%
33:12 inflation, why it's 2%, not three. I'm I'm curious about your take on that
33:16 because I did a little historical uh archaeology. I understand somebody in
33:19 New Zealand came up with the two target as opposed to 2.5 or 1.5 or three. Let's
33:25 put that aside for a second. The thing that I think most Americans don't
33:28 understand and the and the second mandate, full employment, robust
33:31 employment, that seems pretty easy to understand for all of us. But this
33:36 qualit qualitative easing and and how they purchase and which assets they
33:40 purchase and why seems to have a massively distorting effect on the
33:43 economy, at least according to your essay and and some of the other sources
33:48 you cite in this essay, which we have in the notes uh for people to read. What
33:53 should we be doing this qualifi this QE at all? If you had your brothers and you
33:58 could just, you know, swipe a pen here and and clean this up, would you just
34:02 get rid of the QE portion of what they're doing? And how do they pick?
34:06 Like, how do you pick whose corporate debt you buy? You know, are you buying
34:11 Nvidas and Ubers and Google's because those are great companies or Microsofts
34:15 or are you buying, you know, Fords or struggling companies or struggling
34:19 airlines? How are those decisions made? and and should the American people be
34:23 buying those things and why? >> Yeah. So, there's a lot to unpack there,
34:31 uh, that absolutely large-scale asset purchases should be part of the
34:36 so-called central bank toolkit. But I I think if we go back and look at CO,
34:42 which was a real test, the the Bank of England had the best model. The markets
34:47 became unhinged. They stepped in for a period I can't remember whether it was
34:52 30, 60 or 90 days. They stabilized markets and you they they were the buyer
34:58 of last resort which is classic theory for what a central bank's supposed to
35:02 do. They're supposed to provide liquidity. They're supposed to open a
35:07 window where financial institutions can pledge collateral and do it that way.
35:13 Um, and you know, I'll just point out that when the bond yields were quite
35:19 high, the Fed did buy quite a bit. Uh, and they would actually have a large
35:24 profit if they stopped during during that period. Instead, they continued on
35:30 when we were the near near the the zero bound. And what what we've ended up with
35:36 here is they pushed the asset price up. The interest rates were low. Many people
35:41 couldn't buy a house during COVID, but now the interest rate has normalized.
35:45 And you know, we're just in a much more normal period for interest rates, but
35:51 we're not in a normal period for asset prices because so many people still have
35:57 the 3% mortgages from co and back back to your question on what should the Fed
36:02 buy traditionally that the Fed since large scale asset purchases began in 2009, they just
36:10 bought government bonds. They they choose the duration. uh they switched uh
36:17 during COVID because look there there were estimates we were going to have a
36:26 20 30 40% GDP decrease. Um so they they were buying indices of high yield bonds
36:33 of of corporate bonds to stabilize the market. I think what you're alluding to
36:38 Jason is also during that period in conjunction with Treasury uh there were
36:44 bailouts and that's done by a facility that is negotiated between the Fed and
36:50 the Treasury called a 133 facility and you identify strategic industries that
36:56 may be struggling. It it would not have behooved anyone for the airline industry
37:04 to go belly up because of a a virus that turned out to be quite transitory. So,
37:10 you know, again, I I think these are emergency powers. I think they should
37:15 have them in an emergency, but I think the duration went on much much too long. If you're
37:23 now in the bond sales game, Secretary Bessent, I mean, you you've been on the
37:26 other side of the market, but now you're selling the bonds. What do you see in
37:31 terms of appetite for US bonds? Has China disappeared? Are they still
37:35 selling down? Are there other buyers emerging? And how does broader capital
37:42 markets look to US debt in this moment? Well, it's it's like the John Maynard
37:49 Kaine said said a lot lot of economics is is a beauty pageant. You're just
37:53 picking like who do you think's going to win? And that that the U the US became
38:01 the the worldwide winner last year. We had the best performing bond market,
38:06 best performing market since 2020. And I I think that was for a combination of
38:11 reasons. One was the fiscal progress we made and everyone went from the tariffs.
38:21 They were a doomsday machine to hm maybe tariffs are taking us to the promised
38:29 land in terms of fiscal payown. And uh I I also think inflation expectations have
38:34 remained well anchored. Back to Jason's question, why 2%? We've chosen 2%. And
38:44 I I I think it it's very difficult to do a midair refueling or to call an audible
38:50 on two when you're above two because then it looks like when you're above a
38:56 level, you will always fudge upward. So I I think there is a very robust
39:02 conversation to get back once we are back to two which I I think will be in
39:08 sight then we can have a discussion is it much smarter to have a range like
39:13 what what drives me crazy the the economy the markets are biology they're
39:19 not math they're not physics they're they're nonlinearities they're very complex systems they're
39:26 mutations in the system and this idea that we can have this decimal point
39:34 certainty is just absurd. So I I believe that once we re anchor to the target
39:42 then we could talk about a range and we could decide whether the range is from
39:50 2.5 to 1.5 is it from 1 to three but I I think it's very difficult to uh reanchor
39:56 until you meet the target and maintain credibility. Maybe as we wrap up on the
40:01 Fed, can you give us a sense of the candidates that are being interviewed
40:05 right now by President Trump, Kevin Wish, Kevin Hasset, >> Waller,
40:09 >> Chris Waller, and Rick? >> Chris Waller, Rick Reed. How do you
40:13 think each of those will try to reshape the Fed more in this constrained mode
40:19 that you're advocating for? Well, I I I think many many of them have already
40:24 come out and said that they uh do want to shrink it both as the footprint of
40:29 the institution in the economy but shrink the institution itself that the
40:34 the Fed does not as we talked about earlier the the Fed does not rely on
40:38 appropriations. The Fed just prints its own money and it's has its own budget
40:44 and as I talked about in the article it has its own police force. has its own,
40:47 you know, we've seen the big cost overruns at the building uh here in DC.
40:56 If like if Treasury the we're looking at new buildings for the the men of the
41:01 Bureau of Engraving, if we had that kind of cost overrun, I can guarantee you
41:06 that I would be up in Capitol Hill getting a the welldeserved earful.
41:12 >> Yeah. You'd be pillared. Yeah. So, um, but e each one of them
41:20 has talked about moving back toward the more traditional Fed role, [snorts] moving into the just
41:27 getting the Fed back into the background. You know, it it it wasn't
41:32 meant that the market and the economy and the American people were supposed to
41:36 hinge on every word. It was supposed to be a predictable process. You know, I I
41:41 think many many of them have talked about getting rid of this so-called
41:45 dotpot, the summary of economic projections. Uh they they've talked
41:50 about what should we do uh with the regional banks. No one no one's talking
41:53 about getting rid of them or the regional bank presidents, but should
41:58 each one of the regional banks have a specialty, go back to a center of
42:02 excellence? Why do we have so many overlapping functions? Uh, you know, I I
42:08 can tell you for for me as someone who's an economic historian, the interview
42:13 process has been fantastic because I I got to interview 11 of the most
42:18 knowledgeable people on economics, the Fed, monetary policy. One time I got to
42:26 interview five another time and I'll be with four of them with the president.
42:31 So, you know, I I think I understand probably better than just about anybody
42:36 in the country what needs to be done and everyone wants to see a de a smaller
42:43 footprint and more predictability from what's going on. >> So, what happens in 2026 for Main
42:51 Street? What can you promise them? What can you not promise them? What is out of
42:55 your control? because we talk a lot about hey the speed limit and mortgage
43:01 rates but you can't in your position correct me if I'm wrong have a dramatic
43:05 impact on the supply of homes as one example so and so whatever you put the
43:10 rates at it could just drive the prices of those homes up if we lower rates too
43:13 quickly and then we have another situation like the great financial
43:17 crisis where people are over bidding uh the the the remaining housing stock so
43:22 what can you actually promise to the American people will happen in 2026 on
43:25 Main Street. We know Wall Street's going to be fine and and these American
43:29 entrepreneurs and these companies are firing on all cylinders. Fantastic. Lots
43:34 of regulations taken out of the way, but what what can Main Street expect from
43:39 the administration in 2026? >> Jason, two two things is one there
43:43 there's nothing I can promise because that there's always a degree of
43:48 uncertainty. Uh but one one of the things that we've been doing here at
43:52 Treasury when we talk about loosening the financial regulations
43:58 that the companies that suffered the most under these regulations were the small banks.
44:05 So we have seen small and community banks disappear at an alarming rate.
44:11 About half of them have disappeared since the GFC. So I what I can promise
44:18 is that the regulatory regime for those banks is being loosened and is the the
44:26 saying that there's three eight banks in the US that are too big to fail that the
44:32 policies since the GFC were too small to succeed and we are doing everything to
44:40 unleash the lending capability of these banks the pro their profit profitability
44:44 will enable them to be part of their communities to lend more.
44:52 70% I think I do the statistics 70% of a lending 30 40% of real estate lending
44:58 40% of small business lending are from these main street lenders. So I can tell
45:02 you there's going to be a bigger availability of credit. I can tell you
45:07 that we are not going to blow out the budget deficit and cause you you will
45:14 not see an MIT study that says that the Trump 2.0 caused inflation through the
45:21 budget deficit. And I I can also tell you that we are working to increase
45:27 working wages. In President Trump's first term, hourly workers did better
45:32 than supervisory workers. bottom 50% of households had a better increase in net
45:36 bigger increase in net worth than the top 10%. So you know we we are trying to
45:43 level the playing field. Secretary Bessent, this is a I I would say
45:49 conservative administration. And if you look at the kind of economic
45:54 policy of of traditional conservative administrations, you would not assume
45:59 that the administration would lead the federal government to make large
46:03 investments in the private industry or to participate meaningfully in the
46:08 economy. As we are seeing with some of the deals that have been done over the
46:12 last couple of months where the the administration has taken equity stakes
46:18 in key industries and key businesses and also has concurrently provided either
46:23 regulatory unlock or or some sort of trade participation. Can you just
46:27 comment on what some people are calling state capitalism? Is this from your view
46:33 a a set of strategic interests or is this a permanent shift in how the the
46:38 government plays a role in the economy and and and how does that make sense
46:42 from a free market perspective? David, I think it goes back to the idea that free
46:48 pure unfettered free trade was not fair trade. when when you have competitors
46:54 whether they're chi China, Vietnam, some others uh sometimes in in Europe that
47:02 have high subsidies then like this idea that perfect ricardian equivalents exist
47:08 doesn't and we can see by these distortions that developed the these
47:13 huge capital pools that have developed because of the imbalances. So if that's
47:20 one point but and that's trade policy but on the other side there's national
47:25 security policy and the only good thing I can say about co is it woke us up to
47:31 the national security took us out of this paradigm that elongated free
47:39 flowing the supply chains wherever they may be were the best that the um the the
47:46 most smoothly functioning was desirable. Well, it it turns out
47:51 that the most efficient is not always the safest, the most robust or the
47:58 soundest. And we saw that during co we we discovered that the Chinese became
48:04 unreliable suppliers. Uh India and some of the other countries they acted
48:08 surprise surprise in their national interest. So uh what we if you look at
48:15 the industries where we are taking stakes and moving forward we've
48:20 identified five to eight strategic industries where the US we have to have
48:27 endogenous production or at least adjacent to us the in North America or
48:36 this hemisphere. Um we and I I think of it as it's the kind of thing that you
48:43 would have seen during World War II and we are in an economic war and we do not
48:49 want it to become a kinetic war but we have to be prepared if if it could but
48:55 when when we think about huge amount 80 90% of the precursor chemicals that go
49:01 into US pharmaceuticals are made overseas majority in China or India semiconductors in in
49:12 my life I believe that the greatest economic threat to the world economy to
49:19 the US economy more than the Arab oil embargo that I lived through in the 70s
49:24 when I was lined up with my parents to the at the pump to do odd even days
49:30 because of the oil embargo. The biggest threat is that 97% of the upper level precision chip
49:39 manufacturer, the advanced chip manufacturers is made in Taiwan and we
49:44 need to bring a portion of that back to the US. Uh same for steel, same for ship
49:52 building, same for pharmaceuticals. So the interventions are all the in those
49:58 areas. Scott, as we wrap, I'd like to go back to one topic you spoke about at the
50:03 beginning, which is you've had to overcome a lot of Biden era difficulty
50:08 and a lot of the groundwork, as you said, will be seen in 26 and beyond. And
50:12 I just want to give you a final moment to talk about those in two buckets.
50:16 Bucket number one is there's a lot of tax cuts that will hit starting January
50:20 1. And I think it would be good for people to understand what's coming. And
50:25 then bucket number two, there's been this incredible movement and energy
50:30 around Trump accounts. And you even spoke about this yesterday about the
50:33 value of compounding and teaching people the financial literacy to understand
50:37 what's possible for all these kids. And I just want to give you a chance to talk
50:40 about those two topics as we wrap. >> Couple points here. what we are going to
50:47 see next year that if you think about the the signature parts of the the tax
50:52 bill I I think that the powerful the most powerful parts uh had uh the
50:58 immediate expensing for American business uh permanent for equipment
51:03 and then four or five year window for factories so we are seeing already seeing a capex
51:13 boom so 2025 was a capex boom. I think that is going to accelerate with all the
51:18 trade deals we've done. I was just about 6 weeks ago in my hometown of
51:22 Charleston, South Carolina, Boeing, the largest employer there, is increasing
51:28 their plant by 50% for the Dreamliners result of the trade deals, but it's also
51:34 part of the tax deal. So, we're going to continue seeing this capex boom that
51:38 turns into an employment boom. on the other side for working Americans. The
51:45 president I I led the administration's team up on the hill uh
51:51 in terms of what was non-negotiable non-negotiable for the president and a
51:57 lot of traditional Republicans didn't like his campaign promises to working
52:01 Americans and the president never yielded on those. No tax on tips, no tax
52:06 on overtime, no tax on social security, deductibility of auto loans for
52:11 Americanmade cars. So the the bill was done on July 4th. It's retroactive to
52:17 the beginning of the year for working Americans, retroactive to January 20th.
52:22 uh for corporates. So, working Americans, I I also have the honor of
52:27 being the IRS commissioner, and I can see that we're going to have a gigantic
52:33 refund year in the first quarter because no one changed their working Americans
52:38 did not change their withholding. So I I think households could see depending on
52:44 the the number of workers $1,000 $2,000 refunds they will change their
52:49 withholding schedule at the beginning of the year and they will get an automatic
52:54 increase the in real wages. So I think that's going to be a very uh I I think
53:00 that's going to be a very powerful combo of corporate and individuals. And then
53:08 the the these Trump accounts I believe are a gamecher and I think this will end
53:15 up more than what he did for defense, more than he did for strategic
53:20 industries. When we look back in 50 years, I think this administration will
53:26 have saved or created the idea that everyone is an equity owner, that
53:31 everyone has a stake in the market. Right now, about 38% of Americans do not
53:38 own equities either directly or through some kind of a 401k or something. So by
53:46 giving every child $1,000 at birth the for these accounts we are going to
53:50 increase financial literacy. We're going to increase people's optimism in the
53:55 market here at Treasury. We're going to do the a dramatic amount of financial
54:00 literacy, financial education. We're going to push that out to the schools.
54:06 And I I think this idea of every American learning h that money can make
54:12 money for them that you know we we will close the gap over time. We'll go from
54:18 38% not owning equities that if this continues hopefully that can be zero and
54:24 everybody gets a stake in American prosperity that the American innovation that you
54:32 all do and I I think it is going to you when I look at sort of the the polling
54:37 for young people in terms of their view of socialism, their their view of
54:42 capitalism, I I think that this is going to make you know every man Huey Long
54:47 said, "Every man a king." I think this is going to make a the every the man and
54:55 woman a a a market participant. And I think it's fantastic. It I began the
55:00 announcement the other day. I said, you know, I've talked about parallel
55:04 prosperity, Wall Street and Main Street. This is the biggest merger in history
55:09 because it is merging Main Street and Wall Street. And I I grew up in a small
55:15 town in South Carolina. The only thing I knew about Wall Street was something bad
55:19 had happened in 1929 and I was fortunate went to Yale and then u went to New York. But you you
55:27 shouldn't have to have that path that if you want to stay in your hometown but
55:31 participate in the market and learn a lot about it, this is the ultimate
55:36 program for that. And what we're doing is parents, family members, employers
55:43 can add $5,000. Philanthropists like Susan Michael Dell are going to put
55:50 in $6.25 billion to top up the accounts. And then we're up to probably 20 states
55:57 that are going to also top up the accounts. Uh employers, we've got uh credit card companies,
56:04 banks that are already on board. and you're just going to keep pushing more
56:09 money into these accounts. Americans are the most generous people in the history
56:14 of the world. We have never had a direct way to get rid of the friction of
56:19 philanthropy and give money directly to American children. >> Yeah. Fantastic.
56:25 >> A real watershed moment. Um, Secretary Bessant, we appreciate your leadership
56:29 and your service and for spending the time with us here today. You've been
56:34 open and articulate as always and we thank you for that. We appreciate it.
56:39 For Chimath Jason, this is the uh the All-In podcast and thank you Secretary
56:42 Besson. >> Good. Well, it's an honor to serve the American people. So, thank you all.
$

Scott Bessent: Fixing the Fed, Tariffs for National Security, Solving Affordability in 2026

@theallinpodcast 56:57 7 chapters
[security and privacy][productivity and workflows]
// chapters
// description

(0:00) Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent joins the show (0:55) Recapping 2025 and the state of the economy (3:13) Tariffs: Leverage, legal challenges, implementation (15:20) Affordability: inflation, BLS data, interest rates (23:00) The Fed: biggest mistakes, how we got a 15 year asset bubble, rate cycle, appetite for US debt, Fed Chair candidates (42:44) Focus on Main Street, taking equity stakes in American companies (50:40) Tax cuts, Trump accounts, economic legacy Follow Secretary Bessent: h

now: 0:00
// tags
[security and privacy][productivity and workflows]